It's Not Easy Being #1: Camry Incentives Rise High as Toyota Chases 15th Consecutive Year on Top

Timothy Cain
by Timothy Cain

The Toyota Camry began a streak of 14 consecutive years as America’s best-selling car in 2002. Holding that number one position isn’t easy.

Toyota does not merely need the Camry to continue to live up to its reputation for reliability, and subsequently incite demand. Toyota also requires massive production capacity and a pricing scheme that matches production capacity to demand.

Demand in the United States for conventional midsize cars, however, is falling quickly. Year-to-date, overall midsize car volume is down 8 percent. In July 2016, midsize car sales fell 15 percent.

With a 2016 Camry now attempting to leave dealer lots as a five-year-old car, more than two years since its last refresh, Toyota’s desire for the Camry to maintain its high-volume nature and best-selling posture is now matched by a significant uptick in Camry incentives.

Toyota is now discounting Camrys 27-percent more than just one year ago, with an average incentive spend per Camry of $3,760 in July.

According to Autodata figures in this Automotive News article, Toyota has ramped up Camry incentives in nine of the last twelve months, from $2,969 per Camry in July 2015 to $3,459 in December 2015, to the peak of $3,760 per Camry last month.

Year-over-year, Toyota’s average incentive spend per Camry is also up 27 percent through the first seven months of 2016.

As Camry competitors similarly experience disappearing demand, incentives are the name of the game. The Camry is by no means an exception on that front.

Fiat Chrysler Automobiles’ clear out of the nearly discontinued Chrysler 200 (despite the 200 deemed uncompetitive by the collective consumer) puts a measure of pressure on cars such as the new Chevrolet Malibu. Select 2016 Malibu LTs are now advertised with a $4,143 cash back offer, for instance.

On August 10, Ford added $1,000 Smart Bonus Cash to the older half of Fusion stock, and even on some newly refreshed 2017 Ford Fusions.

Until a 26-percent July sales slide dropped it one place, the Nissan Altima was America’s second-best-selling midsize car in 2016. To spur demand, Nissan offers interest-free financing for six years with at least $500 in bonus cash.

The list goes on.

Despite the incentivization, Americans nevertheless purchased and leased 116,000 fewer midsize cars in the first seven months of 2016 than during the same period one year ago.

Toyota appears entirely unwilling to see the ageing Camry lose sales faster than the segment as a whole.

Year-to-date, Camry volume is down 8 percent, a loss of 20,369 sales in a category that is likewise down 8 percent inside a passenger car sector that’s down — you guessed it — 8 percent. The Camry’s 4,313-unit decline played a significant role in the month of July, specifically, as midsize volume plunged by 31,000 sales.

The upside is easy to locate in Toyota showrooms. With similar MSRPs, U.S. sales of the Toyota RAV4 are up 16 percent this year, a year-over-year gain of 27,487 sales, which more than counteracts the lost Camry volume.

The RAV4 isn’t simply keeping pace with growth in the SUV/crossover sector, either. Presently America’s top-selling utility vehicle, the RAV4’s 16-percent volume expansion comes as U.S. SUV/crossover sales grew 8 percent in the first seven months of 2016.

While TrueCar says buyers of the 2016 Toyota Camry XLE are paying 10-percent below MSRP, the 2016 Toyota RAV4 XLE AWD buyer nets only a 3-percent discount.

Through the end of July, the Toyota Camry holds an 11,090-unit lead over America’s second-best-selling car, the Honda Civic. At this stage of 2015, the Camry was 33,871 sales ahead of the next-best-selling car, Toyota’s own Corolla.

The Toyota Camry is by no means dying, but some of its competitors might. TTAC recently forecasted the demise of a number of midsize sedans; that the continued rise of two-row family crossovers will kill off more midsize cars until the segment stabilizes with an appropriate number of competitors.

The significant discounts applied to America’s perennial best-selling car, a midsize Toyota that wears its blue chip credentials on its sleeve, is more evidence of that eventuality.

[Images: Toyota. Chart: © 2016 Timothy Cain/The Truth About Cars]

Timothy Cain is the founder of GoodCarBadCar.net, which obsesses over the free and frequent publication of U.S. and Canadian auto sales figures. Follow on Twitter @goodcarbadcar and on Facebook.

Timothy Cain
Timothy Cain

More by Timothy Cain

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 85 comments
  • CapVandal CapVandal on Aug 18, 2016

    The incentives are up by $500? or $700? That's $20/month on a 36 month lease. Not a game changer for most people. I don't see how that is going to change a lot of minds. This is the last year before a redesign, so they deserve a discount.

  • Paragon Paragon on Aug 18, 2016

    So, does anybody have the nerve to come out and verbalize Toyota's popular old tagline "I love what you do for me...Toyota!" Anybody? Bueller? OK, got nothing as I've never driven a Toyota. But, apparently if given enough of a discount on a rather bland, average sedan with a decent and long-standing reputation for quality and reliability, people will bite. In comparison, my experience in driving a late-model Accord sedan is that the Earth Dreams 4-cylinder coupled to the most refined CVT on the market make for a pleasant and enjoyable driving experience. In some respects, I get what it is that has kept the Accord on Car & Driver's 10 Best list for so many years; yet, at the same time C & D have seemingly ignored some of Accord's minor flaws and/or failings as it fails to be the perfect car. Hint: the seats are less than ideal. As has been said many times, YMMV.

  • Theflyersfan I used to love the 7-series. One of those aspirational luxury cars. And then I parked right next to one of the new ones just over the weekend. And that love went away. Honestly, if this is what the Chinese market thinks is luxury, let them have it. Because, and I'll be reserved here, this is one butt-ugly, mutha f'n, unholy trainwreck of a design. There has to be an excellent car under all of the grotesque and overdone bodywork. What were they thinking? Luxury is a feeling. It's the soft leather seats. It's the solid door thunk. It's groundbreaking engineering (that hopefully holds up.) It's a presence that oozes "I have arrived," not screaming "LOOK AT ME EVERYONE!!!" The latter is the yahoo who just won $1,000,000 off of a scratch-off and blows it on extra chrome and a dozen light bars on a new F150. It isn't six feet of screens, a dozen suspension settings that don't feel right, and no steering feel. It also isn't a design that is going to be so dated looking in five years that no one is going to want to touch it. Didn't BMW learn anything from the Bangle-butt backlash of 2002?
  • Theflyersfan Honda, Toyota, Nissan, Hyundai, and Kia still don't seem to have a problem moving sedans off of the lot. I also see more than a few new 3-series, C-classes and A4s as well showing the Germans can sell the expensive ones. Sales might be down compared to 10-15 years ago, but hundreds of thousands of sales in the US alone isn't anything to sneeze at. What we've had is the thinning of the herd. The crap sedans have exited stage left. And GM has let the Malibu sit and rot on the vine for so long that this was bound to happen. And it bears repeating - auto trends go in cycles. Many times the cars purchased by the next generation aren't the ones their parents and grandparents bought. Who's to say that in 10 years, CUVs are going to be seen at that generation's minivans and no one wants to touch them? The Japanese and Koreans will welcome those buyers back to their full lineups while GM, Ford, and whatever remains of what was Chrysler/Dodge will be back in front of Congress pleading poverty.
  • Corey Lewis It's not competitive against others in the class, as my review discussed. https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/cars/chevrolet/rental-review-the-2023-chevrolet-malibu-last-domestic-midsize-standing-44502760
  • Turbo Is Black Magic My wife had one of these back in 06, did a ton of work to it… supercharger, full exhaust, full suspension.. it was a blast to drive even though it was still hilariously slow. Great for drive in nights, open the hatch fold the seats flat and just relax.Also this thing is a great example of how far we have come in crash safety even since just 2005… go look at these old crash tests now and I cringe at what a modern electric tank would do to this thing.
  • MaintenanceCosts Whenever the topic of the xB comes up…Me: "The style is fun. The combination of the box shape and the aggressive detailing is very JDM."Wife: "Those are ghetto."Me: "They're smaller than a Corolla outside and have the space of a RAV4 inside."Wife: "Those are ghetto."Me: "They're kind of fun to drive with a stick."Wife: "Those are ghetto."It's one of a few cars (including its fellow box, the Ford Flex) on which we will just never see eye to eye.
Next