NTSB Looking Into Limo Regulations in Wake of Deadly Crash

Steph Willems
by Steph Willems

The deadliest U.S. transportation accident in the last decade occurred in upstate New York this weekend, but it didn’t involve a airliner, train, or bus. The vehicle in question was a modified 2001 Ford Excursion. All 18 occupants of the aging limo died after the vehicle failed to stop at an intersection, with two pedestrians struck and killed in the parking lot where the runaway vehicle ultimately came to rest.

In the vehicle was a group of young people, including many couples and relatives, who were headed to a birthday celebration. While limo operators are already subjected to federal oversight, the National Transportation Safety Board plans to probe existing regulations as part of its investigation.

According to media reports, the limo failed to stop at T-shaped intersection where Route 30 terminates at Route 30A. A hill and curve precedes the intersection, and eyewitnesses claim the Excursion approached the stop sign at a high rate of speed. It carried on across the roadway, through a ditch and some brush, and into the parking lot of a country store, where it struck a Toyota Highlander and the two pedestrians.

The intersection has been the site of numerous crashes over the years, but nothing like Saturday’s accident. Heavy truck traffic is no longer allowed to operate on that stretch of road.

In a report by the Washington Post, Schoharie Town Supervisor Alan Tavenner said witnesses claim the Excursion hit the intersection going about 60 miles per hour. While a cause for the tragedy has not yet been determined, there’s obvious theories to consider — either the vehicle’s driver failed to anticipate the upcoming intersection, the vehicle’s brakes were not operating properly, or a combination of both. The investigation has only just gotten underway.

Valerie Abeling, whose niece died in the crash and whose daughter was invited on the outing, but couldn’t attend, said her daughter recounted the group renting a bus that broke down before it could reach them. The limo was a backup plan, she said. Minutes before the crash, one of the victims texted her daughter to say, “The vehicle appeared in terrible condition.”

Speaking to CNN, NTSB Chairman Robert Sumwalt said, “We certainly want to look at the regulation of limos. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration does oversee motor carriers so we want to see if the regulation for limousines is adequate.”

He added, “This does need to be a wake-up call.”

While Sumwalk didn’t outline the entirety of the investigation’s scope, he did say it would examine the lack of seatbelts in the back of the stretch limo.

[Image: Wikimedia ( CC BY-SA 2.0)]

Steph Willems
Steph Willems

More by Steph Willems

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 53 comments
  • Jagboi Jagboi on Oct 09, 2018

    I have a space in a parkade that is about half rents by a limo company and have chatted with the maintenance guys there. They say our city has a hard limit of a limo being 10 years old when used for commercial service. There is nothing stopping someone from buying a limo over 10 years old and using it to drive their friends around, but it can't be for hire if over 10 years. I'm sure that's exactly to prevent things like this, if there was rusted brake lines, chassis etc.

  • WildcatMatt WildcatMatt on Oct 10, 2018

    When my wife and I lived in Binghamton and her grandmother lived in Amsterdam, we would take I-88 up to this exit rather frequently; I've actually driven through that intersection several times. The stop is indeed on a long sweep and at the bottom of a long grade that effectively begins where the road crosses over I-88. Personally I never cared for the stop at the bottom; I always preferred to turn at NY-7 before you crossed the interstate down the hill that way instead. It's way too easy to pick up speed there without really noticing. My mother in law had connections to some of the victims, it's mind boggling for an accident of such magnitude to happen in such a small-town area.

  • TheEndlessEnigma My '16 FiST: Oil changes, tires, valve cover gasket (at 112k miles), coolant flush, brakes.....and that's itMy '19 Grand Caravan: Oil changes, coolant flush
  • John Clyne I own a 1997 GMC Suburban that I bought second hand. It was never smoked in but had lost the new car smell when I got it four years after it was sold new. I own a 2005 Chevrolet Avalanche & that still has the new car smell. I like the smell. I could never afford a new car until the Avalanche. It might be my last new car? Why do they build cars with fire retardant materials in them. Smoking rates are falling & if someone continues to smoke in this day & age is a fool especially with all the information out there.
  • Theflyersfan Non-performance models, probably the Civic based on the fact the interior feels and looks better in the Honda. Both of them are going to drive like adequate appliances with small engines and CVTs and get decent mileage, so this is based on where my butt will rest and things my hands and fingers will touch.Toyota doesn't have an answer to the Civic Si so the Honda wins by default.CTR vs GR Corolla. One dealer by me is still tacking on $10,000 markups for the CTR and good luck with the GR Corolla and the "allocation" system. There's that one dealer in Missouri that I pasted their ad a while back wanting $125,000 for a mid-level GR. Nope. But cars.com is still showing markups. Both of these cars will have little depreciation for a while, so the markups equal instant loss. It looks like Cincinnati-area dealers are done with CTR markups. So this is a tough choice. I don't like the Corolla interior. It looks and feels inexpensive. I'm glad Honda toned down the exterior but the excessive wing still looks immature for such an expensive car that 20-somethings likely cannot afford. FWD vs AWD. With price being an object, and long-term maintenance a thing, I'd go with the Honda with a side eye at the Golf R as a mature choice. All with stick shifts.
  • ChristianWimmer Great first car for someone’s teenage daughter.
  • SCE to AUX Imagine the challenge of trying to sell the Ariya or the tired Leaf.
Next