Volkswagen Would Have Seen a Sales Gain If Certain Countries Weren't Basket Cases

Steph Willems
by Steph Willems

The diesel emissions scandal can’t be blamed for all of Volkswagen’s sales woes.

Today, the automaker announced first-quarter profits fell 86 percent compared to the same time last year, not surprising given its sidelined diesel models, the hit to its reputation, and a hastily cobbled together $18.2 billion scandal fund.

Worldwide sales of Volkswagen passenger cars fell 1.3 percent (year-over-year) this quarter, but the scandal doesn’t tell the whole story. That number would have been in positive territory if select countries weren’t grab-your-money-and-get-out economic disasters.

The loss of global sales for the brand amounts to 19,924 vehicles. When deliveries of all Volkswagen Group makes are factored in — every VW, Audi, Skoda, Seat, Bentley, Porsche and Lamborghini — the company posted a sales gain of 0.6 percent.

In any given country, VW makes up the biggest slice of the group’s sales pie — a slice that gets bigger in overseas and developing nations.

Going by the delivery numbers, it looks like economic turmoil in a few countries erased the possibility of overall VW sales growth.

North American countries aren’t among them. The blame for that continent’s first-quarter VW Group sales decline of 2.2 percent (down 5.5 percent in the U.S., 10.6 percent in Canada, and up 10.5 percent in Mexico) falls mainly on the scandal and all those sidelined diesels.

Brazil, a big VW customer now wracked with corruption and a plummeting GDP, is a large part of the picture. Thanks to Brazil’s moribund economy, which Forbes describes as “stuck in the mud and rolling back on a cliff, 10,000 feet above hungry man eating dinosaurs,” sales fell 37.6 percent.

That’s a whopping 38,458 units erased from last year’s first-quarter figures. And the Amarok pickup is the only VW diesel in that country.

Russia, whose economy has been on the skids for some time ( causing some automakers to flee or delay investment), saw its VW Group sales fall 15.5 percent. That’s 6,338 fewer deliveries for a country that declared it didn’t really care about diesel emissions.

Japan’s weak economy and changing demographics pose a challenge even for domestic automakers. For VW, it meant a sales slide of 21.2 percent, or 5,920 fewer deliveries.

These three countries represent the biggest sales drops for the company, and they each have an underlying affliction totally unrelated to the company’s scandal. The brightest light for VW Group, like most automakers, was China. Deliveries were up 6.4 percent (57,311 units), but it wasn’t nearly enough to offset the losses in other key markets.

Unless those markets turn around, it’s going to mean an even steeper uphill climb for the brand.

[Image: Volkswagen of America]

Steph Willems
Steph Willems

More by Steph Willems

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 18 comments
  • Lorenzo Lorenzo on May 31, 2016

    Well, now we know where Marcelo's Brazil reports went. I was wondering what was happening to Fiat in Brazil, since it was ready to overtake Volkswagen there, before the troubles.

    • Seth1065 Seth1065 on May 31, 2016

      Lorenzo, Did I miss the Marcelo's mention, what happen to him, he had a unique take on things

  • Jingo_Balls Jingo_Balls on Jun 01, 2016

    Numbers are great when you cherry-pick them. VAG's EBITDA is up, they have about as much cash on hand as they had this time last year, and their overall profit is steady. Their current liabilities went up because they took some loans, but they also sold a lot of bonds to offset that. They're an incredibly profitable company in great financial shape. Dieselgate is an annoyance, no more. In fact, nobody cares about Dieselgate except regulators, a few investors, and a couple greens who don't and never would own one...if VAG's TDIs came back on the market in NA tomorrow those sales would be nearly as strong as before the scandal. The only concern among current owners is about trade in value - private party sale prices are strong in the parts of the country where these were popular and non-CPO used car sales at dealers are at practically CPO prices. Demand is still strong, but VW dealers can't sell new or CPO. Owners are waiting to see what kind of compensation package comes their way so they're not getting rid of them, so supply is low. America is not the center of the automotive universe, as much as we would like to think we are - after VAG takes the initial loss in whatever quarter the final settlement is announced, they'll bounce right back, mostly in the strength of China's sales. And they won't need government bailouts to do it, either.

  • JLGOLDEN Enormous competition is working against any brand in the fight for "luxury" validation. It gets murky for Cadillac's image when Chevy, Buick, and GMC models keep moving up the luxury features (and price) scale. I think Cadillac needs more consistency with square, crisp designs...even at the expense of aerodynamics and optimized efficiency. Reintroduce names such as DeVille, Seville, El Dorado if you want to create a stir.
  • ClipTheApex I don't understand all of the negativity from folks on this forum regarding Europeans. Having visited the EU multiple times across different countries, I find they are very much like us in North America-- not as different as politicians like to present them. They all aren't liberal "weenies." They are very much like you and me. Unless you've travelled there and engaged with them, it's easy to digest and repeat what we hear. I wish more Americans would travel abroad. When they return, they will have a different view of America. We are not as perfect or special as we like to believe. And no, many Europeans don't look up to America. Quite the opposite, actually.
  • Dwford Let's face it, Cadillac is planning minimal investment in the current ICE products. Their plan is to muddle through until the transition to full EV is complete. The best you are going to get is one more generation of ICE vehicles built on the existing platforms. What should Cadillac do going forward? No more vehicles under $50k. No more compact vehicles. Rely on Buick for that. Many people here mention Genesis. Genesis doesn't sell a small sedan, and they don't sell a small crossover. They sell midsize and above. So should Cadillac.
  • EBFlex Sorry BP. They aren’t any gaps
  • Bd2 To sum up my comments and follow-up comments here backed by some data, perhaps Cadillac should look to the Genesis formula in order to secure a more competitive position in the market. Indeed, by using bespoke Rwd chassis, powertrains and interiors Genesis is selling neck and neck with Lexus while ATPs are 15 to 35% higher depending on the segment you are looking at. While Lexus can't sell Rwd sedans, Genesis is outpacing them 2.2 to 1.Genesis is an industry world changing success story, frankly Cadillac would be insane to not replicate it for themselves.
Next